close logo

Book Review: Bharat That Is India: Reclaiming Our Real Identity by Abhijit Joag

Bharat That Is India by Abhijit Joag is an ambitious cultural history and identity manifesto that seeks to reposition how Indians understand their nation’s roots and civilizational essence. Published in December 2025, the book emerged at a time when debates about India’s identity, its historical memory, and the influence of Western frameworks are sharply felt in public discourse. Its launch at the Indira Gandhi National Centre for the Arts drew scholars, cultural intellectuals, and policymakers, underscoring its relevance in present intellectual currents.  Joag is already known for his in-depth, analytical work on Indian history and culture, aiming to “inform and inspire” readers. The book is seen as a valuable contribution to understanding India’s true historical and cultural identity. 

Joag’s central thrust in this book is a reclamation of India’s indigenous cultural consciousness — a narrative that predates and transcends the modern nation-state. Unlike many histories that interpret India predominantly through colonial or postcolonial lenses, Joag argues that India’s sense of nationhood arises not from 20th-century political constructs but from a continuity spanning more than 5000 years, rooted in spiritual, cultural, and ethical traditions. This includes an emphasis on dharma — a framework of duty, moral order, and social responsibility — and advanced philosophical expressions such as Advaita Vedanta, suggesting an intellectual cohesion that has underpinned Indian thought through centuries.

One of the book’s notable strengths is its broad cultural sweep. Joag does not limit his writing to political history alone; he connects philosophical concepts, Indian knowledge systems, and civilizational self-understanding with the narrative of nation and identity. This helps the reader see India not merely as a geopolitical entity, but as a living continuum of ideas, faiths, and practices that adapt yet endure. 

An entire chapter has been devoted to ancient scientific practices in India, ranging from metallurgy, medicine, and maths. No area of science was left untouched by our ancestors. We were the first knowledge society in the world, and students from all over Asia used to come to study in our universities. It won’t be an exaggeration to say that we laid the foundation of Western civilisation. 

Another chapter that caught my interest was how India was the world’s economic powerhouse, contributing 25% of the world’s GDP, until the arrival of the British. The author delineates in detail how farming, trade, and manufacturing laid the foundation of rich and thriving India. Indians used to raise three crops a year, some 2000 years back while Europe is still not able to achieve that. 

The prose style is clear, accessible, and “encyclopaedic in its scope” while being “free flowing” and engaging, making it accessible to a wider audience. Joag writes with a purposeful clarity that makes complex philosophical ideas readable to a general audience, while still offering sufficient depth for those seeking a serious engagement with India’s intellectual past. The book’s approachable narrative has a potential to make it a popular read among students, thinkers, and cultural enthusiasts alike.  

Critically, the book also enters current debates on cultural authenticity and historical interpretation. By challenging narratives that privilege Western modernity as the default framework for understanding Indian identity, Joag invites readers to re-examine long-held assumptions about secularism, colonial impact, and the role of indigenous knowledge systems. The result is not a neutral history but a decolonial reinterpretation that asserts agency in India’s own civilizational voice.

The book has already received positive reviews from notable figures, including Dr. Vikram Sampath, who called it a “wonderful contribution to Indian historiography”. In sum, Bharat That Is India offers a thought-provoking, culturally rooted argument for reclaiming India’s civilizational narrative. It is a fascinating read for those interested in civilizational history, cultural self-understanding, and the interplay between past and present identity formation. Whether one agrees with all its conclusions or not, the book succeeds in sparking a larger conversation about who India is and how its people perceive themselves — a conversation that is likely to inform cultural discourse for years to come.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article belong to the author. Indic Today is neither responsible nor liable for the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity of any information in the article.

More Articles By Author